Penstemon

 Scrophulariaceae

©The World Botanical Associates Web Page
Prepared by Richard W. Spjut
January 2005, Updated July 2005; August 2006, June 2007, Dec 2013, Feb 2014, May 2014, Apr 2015, June 2015, July 2016

Penstemon anguineus
Red fir forest region, Marble Mts., CA, trail to One-Mile Lake, July 2004

Penstemon anguineus
Shasta Trinity NF, CA, Spjut 14879, July 2003

Penstemon azureus

Klamath NF, Lake-of-the-Island, Marble Mts. Wilderness, CA
Mixed fir and pine forest
5600 ft, July 2006

 

Penstemon baccharifolius
Texas: Amistad Natl. Rec. Area. Spjut & Marin 15161, Nov 2002

Penstemon caesius
Sunday Peak,
Kern Co., CA
Oct 23, 2013

Penstemon caesius
Kern Plateau, Tulare Co., CA
26 June 2015

Penstemon centranthifolius
Pine Canyon Road
Los Angeles Co., CA
April 24, 2012

 

Penstemon cinicola
Winema NF, OR, Spjut 15542, August 2003

 

Penstemon davidsonii
Dogwood Lake, Marble Mts., CA, July 2005

 

Penstemon davidsonii
Shasta Trinity NF., Mt. Shasta, CA, Spjut 14904,
July 2002

 

Penstemon deustus
Trinity River Canyon, CA
Spjut, Miles & Edson 3404, May 1973

β-sitosterol was reportedly isolated from a sample of this species (Hartwell 1976)

 

Penstemon eatonii
Mojave Desert, Clark Co.,
Spring Mts., NV
May 2006

 

Penstemon floridus
Great Basin Desert, 6000 ft., NV in Esmeralda Co. near Lida, June 2007
 

 

Penstemon fruticiformis
Mojave Desert, Kern Co., CA, Spjut 15196, April 2003

 

Penstemon gracilentus
Shasta Trinity NF, CA, Spjut 14916A, July 2002

 

Penstemon grinnellii
Kern Co., CA: Breckenridge Mt., near junction with Bodfish-Lake Isabella Rd
23 May 2012

 

Penstemon humilus
Cascades-Modoc Co., CA, Spjut & Casterline 14785,
June 2002

 

Penstemon grinnellii var. scrophularioides
Los Angeles Co., Pine Canyon Rd, CA. 24 Apr 2014

 

Penstemon grinnellii var. grinnellii
Kern Co.: Piute Mt., June 9, 2016

Penstemon heterophyllus
Kern Co., CA: Breckenridge Mt., near junction with Bodfish-Lake Isabella Rd
23 May 2012

 

Penstemon heterophyllus
Tehachapi Mts., above Bear Valley Springs, Kern Co., CA
14 June 2012
 

 

Penstemon incertus
Kern Co.: Piute Mt., Kelso Valley region, June 14, 2016

 


Penstemon incertus
Mojave Desert, Joshua Tree Woodland, Kern Co., CA, Spjut & Casterline 15353,
June 2002

 

Penstemon incertus
Kern Co., CA: Southern Sierra Nevada/Tehachapi Mts., Pacific Crest Trail near Hwy 58
7 June 2012

 

Penstemon labrosus
Kern Co., CA. Mt. Pinos, 13 July 2016.

 

Penstemon laetus
Kern Co.: Tehachapi Mts.,
above Bear Valley Springs, CA
16 July 2014

Penstemon monoensis
Mojave Desert, Inyo Co.,
Hills above Owens Valley, CA
May 2006, Photo on right by Susan Spjut

 

Penstemon nemorosus
Gifford-Pinchot NF, WA, Spjut 15536, August 2003

 

Penstemon newberryi
Sierra NF, CA, Spjut 14943, July 2002

 

Penstemon newberryi
Kern Plateau, Tulare Co., CA
26 June 2015

Penstemon newberryi
Kern Co., Piute Mt. CA, 
vicinity of Piute Peak, June 1, 2013. CNPS Chapter field trip. 

 

Penstemon pachyphyllus
Nevada—Calcareous Mts. White Pine Co., Humboldt-Toiyabe NF, Ely Ranger Dist.: Schell Creek Range, Connor Pass, south  side off Hwy 50/6; 39º02'00.4", 114º58.45.7", 2414 m.  Pinyon-juniper woodland on limestone derived soil. Glaucous perennial with several to many erect stems; flowers purple.  Locally common.  Sample of entire plant (rt-st-lf-fl-fr).
Richard Spjut & Paul Burchstead 16357, 22 June 2008

Penstemon palmeri
Mojave Desert, Clark Co.,
Sandy Springs Rd, NV
Apr 2005; May 2006

 

Penstemon palmeri
Mojave Desert, Clark Mt., CA
Spjut & Marin 14728, May 2002

 

Penstemon parryi
Coronado NF, AZ, Spjut & Casterline 14650, March 2002

 

Penstemon parryi
Coronado NF, AZ, Oak Woodland, 15 miles NW of Nogales, Spjut 3326, April 1973

 

Penstemon procerus

Oregon—Cascade Region. Willamette NF: between Santiam Pass and junction of Hwy 22 and Hwy 20, Lost Lake, north side of  Hwy 20; 44º25'48.2", 121º54’46.7”, 1213 m.  Lodgepole pine forest.  SPJ-16426, 15 Aug 2008

  

Penstemon roezlii
Shasta Trinity NF, CA, Spjut 14909, July 2003

 

Penstemon rostriflorus
White Mts., Cerro Gordo, CA, June 2007
  

Penstemon rostriflorus
Kern Co., CA. Mt. Abel, 29 June 2016
 

Penstemon rostriflorus
Kern Plateau, Tulare Co., CA
26 June 2015

 

 

Penstemon speciosus

Oregon. Blue Mountains. Wallowa NF, south of Lick Creek, elev. 6,000 ft., 29 July 2011

Penstemon spectabilis
Peninsular Ranges, CA
San Diego Co. near Riverside Co. line E of I-15, Spjut, Marin, Cragg & Carlton 4716; May 2002

 

Penstemon spectabilis
San Diego Co. near Valley Center.  June 2006

 

 

Trees and Shrubs of Kern County (Nov 2012, July 2016)

Penstemon (Chelonaceae). Perennial herbs, subshrubs, or shrubs; leaves usually opposite, upper sometimes alternate; flowers of united tubular petals (corolla), forming a cylindrical to inflated tube, similar to the throat of a bull frog, with three lower and two upper short lobes, the lobes spreading to erect; fertile stamens 4, inserted at two levels in pairs; staminode bearded or not; capsule similar to that of Keckiella. ±271 species concentrated in western North America, south to Guatemala.

Key to Penstemon shrubs and subshrubs

1. Flowers red to rose or pink..................................................................................... 2

1. Flowers blue to lavender........................................................................................ 5

 

2. Low matted shrubs on rocks, usually granite; leaves
round; flowers rose...............................................................................................             Penstemon newberryi

2. Plants erect; leaves sword-shaped; flowers red...................................................... 3

 

3. Leaves wider near base, clasping the stem; corolla trumpet shaped,
lower three lobes not much larger than upper lobes; Temblor Range
to Fort Tejon......... .................................................. Penstemon centranthifolius

3. Leaves relatively narrow throughout, or narrowed to base, not
clasping; dolphin-like in shape, lower lobes long reflexed
(like fins), upper shortly notched........................................................................ 4

 

4.  Leaves green or yellow green; corolla glandular; mature anthers
shaped like a pair of pants zipped open across the top; rock outcrops,
conifer forests, Sierra Nevada, Tehachapi Mts,
Mt Abel  ...................................................  ..................... Penstemon rostriflorus

4.  Leaves glaucous; corolla smooth; mature anthers shaped like a pair of
diverged opposite pea pods zipped open across the bottom; rock outcrops,
conifer forests; Mt Pinos........................... ......................... Penstemon labrosus

 

5. Leaf blades near base of plant elliptical to round,1–3× longer
than wide, narrowed to a long petiole................................................................ 6

5. Leaf blades strap-shaped to boat-shaped, >3× longer than wide, with short
to no petiole........................................................................................................ 7

 

6. Leaf blades broad elliptic to round, abruptly narrowed to petiole
about as long as blade............................................................ Penstemon caesius

6. Leaves blades longer than wide, gradually narrowed to petiole. Penstemon laetus

 

7.  Lower stem leaves with broad slightly ±elliptic blades, toothed along
margins................................................................................ Penstemon grinnellii

...... 6a. Corolla 22–30 mm, whitish lavender to pink.. .......................... var. grinnellii

...... 6a. Corolla larger, 26–35 mm, blue-violet........................... var. scrophularioides

7.  Lower stem leaves with relatively narrow blades, usually narrower below
mid region, or slightly widened near base, entire to remotely
toothed along margins......................................................................................... 8

 

8. Flowers-fruits reflexed on erect-straight pedicels; corolla grandually
expanded from tubular base; anthers dehiscing
only part way near base; stems and leaves green......... Penstemon heterophyllus

...... 7a. Stems bald, except near base............................................. var. heterophyllus
7a. Stems short hairy....................................................................... var. australis

8. Flowers-fruits erect to slightly reflexed on ascending or curved
pedicels; corolla abruptly expanded (appearing bloated) from tubular
base; anthers dehiscing fully; stems and leaves gray green (glaucous)............... 9

 

9. Corolla without red lines.............................. ........................... Penstemon incertus

9. Corolla with red lines, especially lower lobes.......... ........ Penstemon fruticiformis

...... Corolla externally glandular......................................................... var. amargosae

...... Corolla externally lacking glands or hairs................................ var.  fruticiformis

 Penstemon caesius A. Gray 1883.  Plants with woody leafy stems, loosely branched near ground, mat-like, with erect flowering stems < 1 m high; leaves spoon-shaped on petioles about the same length as blades, 1.5–4.3 cm, whitish green or glaucous, curved upwards lengthwise along the mid region, reduced on flowering stems; flowers Jun–Aug, lavender, slightly inflated and tubular, nodding from straight spreading to curved pedicel-like branches (peduncles), with short bract-like leaves at base of shorter pedicels, appearing solitary on a peduncle but often accompanied by a less developed flower; anthers dehiscent about half-way from base, with prominent short teeth along suture, without hairs.  Rocky ridges and slopes in subalpine open coniferous forests, 6,000–11,000 ft; Southern Sierra Nevada and San Bernardino Mts. Type from San Bernardino Mts., CA.  Kern Co.: “A characteristic plant of rocky places at high elevations in the yellow pine and red fir forests”, “Sunday Peak and Black Mountain the Greenhorn Range and on the rocky southwestern rim of the Kern Plateau” (Twisselmann), 2,000–2,468 m (CCH).

Penstemon centranthifolius Bentham 1835. Scarlet bugler. Stems woody mostly near root, solitary, or numerous and bunched together near base, erect, mostly simple, leafy about half of their length, glaucous, to 1.5 m high; leaves conspicuously glaucous, larger in the mid region of stems, sword-shaped, 4–10× longer than wide, 4–10 cm long, clasping the stem; flowers Apr–Jul, scarlet, on erect pedicels arising from simple (undivided) scapes (inflorescence raceme) with reduced leaves, nodding ±in the same direction, corolla long tubular, with short erect to slightly spreading lobes, 2–3 cm long, anthers dehiscing fully, without hairs. Disturbed places, chaparral or oak woodland below 6,000 ft; Coast Ranges from Lake Co to San Diego Co, Sierra Nevada to southwestern edge of the Mojave Desert, and Baja California. Type from “Nova, California.” Kern Co.: “Occasional in the Upper Sonoran shrubby associations from the Temblor Range southeast to Ft. Tejon” (Twisselmann), 914–1,524 m (CCH).

Penstemon fruticiformis Coville 1893. Desert mountain penstemon. Rounded bush with numerous erect closely compacted stems, 0.5–1.5  m; stems pale green-to bluish green (glaucous) without hairs, leafy to flowering scapes; leaves generally blade-like, nearly uniform in width, slightly wider near base, 4–10× longer than wide, 2.5–6.5 cm, slightly clasping stems, gradually reduced up the stem, curled upwards lengthwise and often bending downwards; flowers Apr–Jun, whitish blue to rose or lavender, on ascending or curved pedicels in unequal pairs—one on a shorter pedicel than the other, peduncles and pedicels mostly without hairs, or in var. amargosae short gland tipped hairs developing along one side in a line; corolla without hairs, or with scattered short gland-tipped hairs in var. amargosae; anthers dehiscing fully; staminode extending beyond the anthers to the lower corolla lobes, like a tooth-brush—with stiff erect white hairs. Creosote scrub to pinyon-juniper woodland, 1,000–8,000 ft, northern Mojave Desert mountains and western southern Sierra Nevada, California and western Nevada.  Type from Wild Rose Canyon, Panamint Mts., Inyo Co., CA; var. amargosae Keck 1917, type from Amargosa Desert, Nye Co., NV.  Kern Co.:  Western border of Mojave Desert, Southern  Sierra Nevada, east of Walker Pass, L. D. Benson,10 May 1947 (CCH–NY); Spjut, 10 Apr 2003 (BRIT, US); Tehachapi Mts, northern Antelope Valley, O. & C. Mistretta, 10 May 2010 (CCH-RSA), between Willow Springs and Tehachapi, Abrams & McGregor, 25 Jun 1908 (CCH-A).

Penstemon grinnellii Eastwood 1905 var. grinnellii. Grinnell’s Penstemon. Rounded bush, woody at base; leafy stems bald, creeping, branching and ascending to 40 cm from which numerous erect terminal flowering stems extend the plant further in height to 1 m or more; leaves green, elliptical to wider below mid region, boat-shaped—curved upwards lengthwise along mid region and arched downwards towards tip (recurved), 3–5×  longer than wide, 5–9 cm long, narrowed to short petiole, or blade attached to stem without clasping, toothed along margins; flowers May–Aug, pinkish white or pale lavender, the tube and throat inflated like a bull-frog; flower scapes (rachis of inflorescence) glandular, with slender ascending lateral branchlets bearing 4–5 flowers each on erect pedicels, or flowers mostly in pairs, with one ascending and the other erect; anthers dehiscing fully; staminode curved and exserted with crested yellowish orange or white hairs spreading in various directions. Chaparral, foothill and pinyon/juniper woodland, montane forest, 1,000–8,000 ft; Southern Sierra Nevada to Peninsular Ranges. Type from Mt. Wilson. Kern Co.: CCH—Trail to Owens Peak, near creek,2,000 m (Fraga & Griffith, 26 Jun 2003, RSA), Bodfish (Jepson, 6 May 1940, JEPS), Scodie Canyon, 26 Apr 2014, Gardner & Poutasse, RSA).

Penstemon grinnellii var. scrophularioides (P. scrophularioides M.E. Jones 1908) N.H. Holmgren 1992. Reportedly larger than the typical variety with blue violet instead of pinkish flowers. Chaparral, foothill and pinyon/juniper woodland, montane forest; 1,600–9,000 ft. Santa Clara Co. south along the Coast Ranges across the Transverse Ranges, north to southern Sierra Nevada. Type from Keane [Kern Co.], CA. Kern Co.: “Occasional in the arid Upper Sonoran associations from Ballinger Canyon in the Mt. Abel region northeast though the mountains canyons to Inyo County” (Twisselmann); Greenhorn Range, Breckenridge  to Tehachapi Mt., Temblor Range, Mt. Pinos, 510–2,210 m (CCH).

Penstemon heterophyllus Lindley 1836. var. heterophyllus. Chaparral penstemon.  Rounded bush to 1.5 m; woody near base; stems leafy, ascending to erect, green or glaucous; leaves green, often in axillary clusters, narrow and strap-like, often  >10× longer than wide, 2–9 cm long, usually more gradually narrowed to base than apex, not clasping; flowers Apr–July, blue to lavender, shortly narrow-tubular and inflated above like a wine-glass; on straight erect pedicels without peduncles (racemose), often appressed to the bald flowering stems; anthers opening up to 2/3; staminode curved and beardless. Foothill woodland, chaparral, “yellow pine forest” below 5,500 ft. Type from California without specific location. Kern Co.: “Occasional in the chaparral and Douglas oak woodland in the Temblor Range” (Twisselmann, not distinguished to variety), San Emigdio Range. Pine Mt., Black Bob Canyon, 914–1,982 m (CCH, distinguished only to species). Var. australis Munz & I.M. Johnston 1932 (Tehachapi Mts. D. Howe, Jun 1932, CCH; type from Claremont).

Penstemon incertus Brandegee 1899. Mojave Penstemon. Rounded bush to 1 (-2) m high and in diam; woody stems several or more, dichotomously branched one or more times; leafy stems on new season growth; young stems glaucous; leaves glaucous, narrow strap-like or narrow sword-shaped,  5–10× longer than wide, 4–7 cm long, usually more gradually narrowed to apex than base, not clasping, reduced up the stem; flowers May–Jun, blue to violet or purple, shortly broad-tubular and inflated above like a bull frog, on wide spreading peduncles with upcurved pedicels and leaf-like bracts at base, solitary or in pairs; anthers dehiscing fully; staminode curved and bearded. Gravel slopes and flats, Joshua tree woodland and sagebrush scrub, 3,000–5,500 ft; Southern Sierra Nevada and Mojave Desert, south to Peninsular Ranges.  Type from Walker Pass [Kern Co.].  Kern Co.: “Common in the Walker Pass region, west in South Fork Valley to Onyx; scarce on Breckenridge Mountains, along the edge of Indian Wells Valley, and in the desert canyons south to Pine Tree Canyon” (Twisselmann), 746–1,950 m (CCH).

Penstemon labrosus [P. barbatus (Chelone barbata Cavinlles 1795) var. labrosus A. Gray 1876] Masters ex Hooker f. 1884.  Plants with one to numerous erect mostly simple herbaceous stems bunched together at base to 70 cm high, leafy to inflorescence, woody mostly near root; stems and leaves glaucous, leaves narrowly elliptic to wider above mid region, narrowly elliptic on upper stems, 12–20× longer than wide, 3–9 cm long, more gradually narrowed to stem than to apex; flowers Jun–Aug, red to orange, nodding often > 90° on erect to wide spreading pedicels, in interrupted tight clusters along undivided floral scapes; corolla long tubular, not inflated, shaped like a dolphin, with the lower lobes strongly reflex and recurved, upper lobes erect—aligned with corolla tube, 3.2–4.0 cm long, anthers dehiscing distally 2/3, without hairs; staminode not bearded.  Openings in coniferous forests, 4,000–10,000 ft; mountains of southern California to Baja California. Type from Mt. Pinos, CA.  Kern Co.: Common and showy along road banks in the forest regions of Mt Pinos,  1,829–2,679 m (CCH).  One collectin in CCH reported from along the Pacific Crest Trail, on the east side of Mount Jenkins (Fraga & De Groot, 8 Aug 2003), is questionable based on its occurrence outside the more southern range of the species. May be confused with Penstemon rostriflorus, which has similar flowers but notably differs by the pant-like anthers dehising proximally.

Penstemon laetus A. Gray 1859 var. laetus. Gay Penstemon  Perennial herb to short woody near base with  leafy ascending stems and longer erect flowering stems, to 0.75 m high; leaves green, often in fascicles on lower stems, spoon-shaped to boat-shaped, usually more gradually narrowed to base than apex on the lower part of the plant, 1.5–10 cm long; flowers May–Jul, blue to lavender, often more reddish on the tube and blue on the lobes, shortly tubular and inflated above; nodding from straight spreading pedicels; anthers opening from base to 4/5; staminode straight, beardless. Foothill woodland, chaparral, “yellow pine forest” below 5,500 ft. Type from Fort Tejon and vicinity. Kern Co.: “Occasional on rocky slopes in all associations in the mountains” (Twisselmann), 457–1,828 m (CCH).

Penstemon newberryi A. Gray 1857 var. newberryi. Pride-of-the-Mountain. Low ±matted shrubs or subshrubs, ±rounded in outline to 0.4 m or more diam with creeping woody leafy stems, loosely branched near ground, with erect flowering stems to 0.4 m high; leaves not closely overlapping. not in whorl-like arrangements as in P. davidsonii, spoon-shaped to broad elliptical or wider below mid region, 1–2× longer than wide, 1–4 cm, on short petioles ~1/4 length of blade, dark green, slightly cupped or folded upwards lengthwise along midrib, reduced on flowering stems, finely toothed along margins; flowers Jun–Aug, rose red, tubular and slightly inflated, 20–30 mm, ±all nodding in the same direction (“subsecund”) on straight spreading short pedicels in a short linear array (raceme, 10–20 cm or more); anthers exserted, fully dehiscent, covered with woolly hairs; staminode shorter than stamens, bearded.  Talus and rock terraces, 5,000–11,000 ft. from Mt. Shasta, western Nevada to Tehachapi. Type collected near Mt. Lassen. Mountain pride patches recognized in MCV2 when “characteristically scattered with other small herbs such as Streptanthus tortuosus in the subshrub or herbaceous layers; other small shrub and trees <2% in absolute cover.”  Kern Co.: “Colonies grow at the summit of Sunday Peak and on the north slopes of Basket Peak in the Greenhorn Range, around the granite blocks along the southern rim of the Kern plateau, and at Lookout Point in the Piute Mountains” (Twisselmann). 1,554–2,561 m (CCH).  Two other varieties found in northern California to Oregon.

Penstemon rostriflorus Kellogg 1860 [Includes Penstemon bridgesii A. Gray 1868; Penstemon bridgesii var. rostriflorus (Kellogg) Schelle 1903].  Stem , woody mostly near root, solitary. or numerous and bunched together at base, erect, mostly simple to 1.0 m, leafy ~1/4 of the length, yellowish green; leaves narrowly elliptic to wider above mid region, narrowly sword-shaped on upper stems, 8–12× longer than wide, 2–7 cm long, more gradually narrowed to stem than to apex; flowers Jun–Aug, red to orange, nodding often > 90° on erect to wide spreading pedicels, in interrupted tight clusters along undivided floral scapes, lower portion with 2–5 flowers, singles near apex, often developing ± within a directional span of 60°; corolla long tubular, not inflated, shaped like a dolphin, with the lower lobes strongly reflex and recurved, upper lobes erect—aligned with corolla tube, 2.2–3.3 cm long, anthers dehiscing basally 1/4–1/3, without hairs; staminode not bearded. Sagebrush, pinyon-juniper, Gambel oak, ponderosa pine and mountain mahogany communities, 1,650–11,000 ft; Colorado to northwestern New Mexico west to mountains of southern California. Type from crevice of lower Dome at the back of  the Great Tissaac, or South–3,500 ft above Yosemite Valley, Mariposa Co., CA.  Kern Co.: Common and showy in the red fir forest and the higher elevations of the yellow pine forest, often growing around exposed summit rock outcrops” (Twisselmann),  1,584–2,457 m (CCH).


 

General references on Pharmalogical Activity in Penstemon

Wysokinska H. and Z. Skrzypek.   1992.  Studies on iridoids of tissue cultures of Penstemon serrulatus: isolation and their antiproliferative properties. J. Nat. Prod. 55(1): 58–63.  Abstract— Penstemide and serrulatoloside as well as penstemide aglycone and serrulatoloside aglycone were isolated and identified in the calli and suspension cultures of Penstemon serrulatus. The influence of serrulatoloside, penstemide, and its aglycone on the spontaneous proliferation of mouse spleen lymphocytes or hepatoma cells in the Syrian hamster has been estimated in vitro. It has been found that these compounds produce a dose-dependent inhibition of [3H]-thymidine incorporation into the DNA of the examined cells.

Zhou B. N., B. D.  Bahler, G. A. Hofmann,  R. Mattern, R. K. Johnson and D. G.  Kingston. 1998. Phenylethanoid glycosides from Digitalis purpurea and Penstemon linarioides with PKCalpha-inhibitory activity.  J Nat Prod. 61: 1410–1412. “In a continuation of our search for potential tumor inhibitors from plants, it was found that the CH2Cl2-MeOH (1:1) extracts from Digitalis purpurea and Penstemon linarioides both showed PKCalpha-inhibitory bioactivity. Bioassay-directed fractionation of the extract from D. purpurea yielded the new, weakly active phenylethanoid glycoside 2-(3-hydroxy-4-methoxy-phenyl)-ethyl-O-(alpha-L-rhamnosyl)-(1-->3) -O- (alpha-L-rhamnosyl)-(1-->6)-4-O-E-feruloyl-beta-D-glucopy ran oside (1) together with the four known compounds calceolarioside A (2), calceolarioside B (3), forsythiaside (4), and plantainoside D (5). The extract from P. linarioides yielded the three known glycosides leucosceptoside A (6), acteoside (7), and poliumoside (8), together with the iridoid plantarenaloside (9). All of the isolated compounds, except compound 9, showed inhibitory activity against PKCalpha with IC50 values (in microM) of 125 (1), 0.6 (2), 4.6 (3), 1.9 (4), 14.8 (5), 19.0 (6), 9.3 (7), and 24.4 (8).”